• *Note: This review contains affiliate links. If you decide to buy a copy of the Yumi and the Nightmare Painter or complete other purchases there via the links posted here, a small portion may come back to fund this website. :-)*

Yumi and the Nightmare Painter Overview

Author: Brandon Sanderson

Genre: Fantasy

Target Audience: YA or NA

My Rating: Enh…

Back Cover Snippet: 

There is a world. One of endless night, surrounded by an even deeper darkness. Filled with nightmares come to life, twisted shapes that slink to windows and ease open doors, sliding across floors to look down on helpless faces.

There is another world. A bright world, so bright it burns. Filled with stacked stones that call forth miracles, raised by callused hands that tremble in their work, drained with each stone lifted, settled, lifted again.

Between these worlds two souls connect. Collide. Entwine.

A bridge. A path.

A road to both worlds changing forever.

My Thoughts: Somewhat Spoiler Free

You guys…I’m conflicted on this one.

Like I’m a huge Brandon Sanderson fan, so it kinda hurts to say this, but Yumi and the Nightmare Painter was not my favorite. I’ll do my best to describe that without getting into too many spoilers, so more on that later. 

Basically, the premise of the story is the title character, Yumi, lives a life of luxury serving her people in an ancient land. The nightmare painter (who goes by the creative nickname of Painter), lives in a more modern world working his dream job of painting nightmares out of existence.

Through magical circumstances, these two find themselves crossing worlds and essentially living each other’s lives. But unlike most body-switching/ life-swapping stories, every time they swap places the other person is still with them as a spirit. So when Yumi goes to Painter’s world, he follows her around as a spirit that no one else can see and vice versa. As the story goes on they gain a deeper appreciation of each other and (mild spoiler) end up falling in love. 

So Here's My Beef with It...

On its face that’s a cute story, right? It reminded me of Kimi No Na Wa, or Enchantment by Orson Scott Card. But there’s one part of the story that left a bad taste in my mouth. And no, it wasn’t the romance–although to be honest I’m still not the biggest fan of the genre. It always seems so predictable.

But anyway, the thing that didn’t sit right with me on this story were the main characters. I’m sorry, they were just too annoying! And since I know someone’s thinking it yes, I did write an entire novel featuring an annoying anti-hero protagonist (which you can order here, if you haven’t already :-)). However, there is a fine line between writing realistic characters and pushing readers past what their patience can handle. And for me, I felt like this book definitely did more of the latter.

(Yes, I'm using a blog post to promote my own book. Be sure to grab a copy if you haven't already 🙂

Like take Yumi, for example. Home girl is a classic example of toxic femininity. When Painter is in her world, she yells at him, makes him do drills for hours nonstop, and tells him he’s nothing. Then, when it’s her turn to be in the hot seat, she starts crying about how overwhelming it is to be in a different world. Like sheesh, you know who else might be able to relate to that? The guy you were shrieking at for stacking rocks the wrong way.

I thought for sure Yumi would ease up on Painter once she got a taste of how frustrating it can be to have another person’s life thrust upon you. But nope. Instead, Miss Thang decides to go on shopping sprees and eating out with friends. All while spending Painter’s money. 

So yeah, Yumi definitely rubbed me the wrong way. But Painter wasn’t much better. As annoying as Yumi was, he was equally frustrating. For the first half of the book, he rolls over every time she makes some ridiculous demand. He complains about it in his mind, but never asks her to stop treating him like a dog. Eventually he kiiiiinda stands up for himself. But by the time that happens I had basically lost all respect for him as a character.

Don’t get me wrong, the love story was cute. But as far as character development goes the payoff wasn’t quite there. Yumi never apologizes for being a total tyrant. And while Painter resolves most of his past issues, he never has that moment where he realizes he shouldn’t be pushed around. The way that he always puts others before himself is sweet, but I thought it was a setup to explore how giving too much of yourself isn’t healthy, either. And that never got addressed.

Interior Illustration from the book. Find more at BrandonSanderson.com

Not My Favorite, but Still a Good Read

In spite of its flaws, Yumi and the Nightmare Painter does have a lot going for it. Like any Brandon Sandrson book, the worldbuilding is fantastic. In Painter’s world, he uses his skill as an artist to trap nightmares roaming the night. Yumi summons spirits with her powers of investiture. And for fans of anime and Korean dramas, this book has a ton of Asian pop culture references.

If you’re the average reader who doesn’t like to rip stories apart the way I do, I think you’ll find this one enjoyable. At its core, Yumi and the Nightmare Painter is a romance about two people from different worlds finding each other. Once Yumi and Painter get over themselves (which takes longer than I would’ve liked), their love story becomes much more enjoyable.

Anyway, that’s gonna do it for this review. If you’ve already read Yumi and the Nightmare painter, please let me know your thoughts in the comments. If you’re interested in checking this book out for yourself please consider using my affiliate links to snag a copy from Amazon or Barnes & Noble, and I’ll see you guys in the next one.